"One Night in Miami" Film Review
By: Keaton Marcus
One Night in Miami. The first new release I’ve seen in 2021. And it wasn’t even a 2021 movie.
Regina King’s much-anticipated directorial debut, One Night in Miami, landed on Amazon Prime Video last night after so much fanfare leading up to its release. Although parts of the movie devolve into mediocrity, for the most part, this is exceptional for a first film and still fairly impressive as a movie in itself. With clearly capable performers and a timeless subject, this was a generally enthralling movie (it picked up considerably after the first 30 minutes) that makes up for its lack of creative stylistic choices easily. Both King and the lead actors, Leslie Odom Jr., Kingsley Ben-Adir, Aldis Hodge, and Eli Goree are incredible talents, and I will not be surprised in the slightest if one, or even several of them receive Oscar nominations this April. It’s been a big year for Prime Video, especially in terms of diversity, so it’s only the right thing to do to spoil them during awards season.
What’s really interesting about this film is it isn’t actually a biopic, which many people will likely expect going into this. The film is set in 1964 Miami, a time, which, as you’d expect, wasn’t exactly the greatest for black people. Cassius Clay, who would later become known as Muhammad Ali, is quickly climbing the ranks as a rookie boxer. Malcolm X, a radical civil rights speaker, continues to run his controversial “white people demonizing” campaign, Sam Cooke is one of the most successful African American songwriters, but he’s having trouble winning over the white audience, and Jim Brown is widely known as the best player in the NFL. Coming off of a major victory, Clay decides to celebrate by joining Brown, Cooke and X at Malcolm’s hotel. As I mentioned, the meet-up between these four icons never actually happened, but it’s incredible to imagine what they would have talked about together. Almost stuck in this one hotel room, the men discuss the responsibilities of being a black man during the civil rights movement.
Getting onto the stuff I liked about this film, there are many things to talk about. First of all, I thought the exchanges between the four men were some of the best scenes in 2020, and the chemistry between the actors was simply simmering. I’ll talk more about the actual performances later, but here I want to get a little deeper into the script. Written by Kemp Powers, who also wrote the play of which this is based on, is truly a brilliant man. Sam Cooke and Malcolm X have extraordinary fights and conversations that asks a few incredibly poignant questions. Are all white people the same? Will they ever be won over or respect black people? As a famous African American at the time, do you have the responsibility to use your fame as a platform to promote civil rights? Although readers may be thinking that these types of questions only apply to situations in the 60s, and when racism was at large, think about what’s been going on recently. Racism hasn’t simply disappeared, it has just taken a more modern form that we are commonly oblivious to. If we really think deeply about recent years and all the chaos towards black people, it seems pretty similar to how it was six decades ago. Overall, I found the script to be the highlight of this film, and if Powers, who is also credited as the screenwriter for Pixar’s gorgeous Soul, doesn’t get nominated, I will be very surprised.
Second of all, these performances were all fantastic. Every single one of them. What stood out for me was the choice to make them the entire cast. What do I mean by that? There weren’t really any supporting characters. All the people you focused on were these black icons, and although it would have been interesting to see more of the world around them, it also never distracted from what was important. The absolute best performance for me was Leslie Odom Jr.’s Sam Cooke, who with both Hamilton earlier this year and now this, is destined to get a nod from the Academy. Him and Kingsley Ben-Adir (who portrayed Malcolm) had some really extraordinary scenes together that asked the questions that I elaborated on earlier. Odom Jr. was especially perfect when his character realized that he has been taking his fame for granted, which was a rare thing for a black man at the time. He wasn’t using his massive following to promote racial equality, and Ben-Adir is also brilliant when he points that out. On the other hand, when we start to see some of the cracks in Malcolm’s arguments, the dynamic of power switches. It’s incredible to witness. Both Aldis Hodge and Eli Goree were both charismatic and perfectly casted, although I would have enjoyed to see them get the spotlight a little more.
In terms of actual negatives, there really isn’t anything that I really disliked about the movie, only things that I thought could be improved. To start it off, it would have to be the directing. Yes, as I wrote, I do understand that this is quite impressive for a first-time movie, but I found the direction from King to be generally mediocre and generic. There weren’t any cool stylistic choices or certain vibes that something like Steve McQueen’s Small Axe series had. Especially through most of the first act, I felt it was really cookie-cutter, despite not being nearly as unbearable as Aaron Sorkin’s direction in The Trial of the Chicago 7. Kemp Powers’ script is something that truly carried the behind-the-camera work because it’s so revolutionary in the questions that it asks. Otherwise, this is more or less connected to the style, but the cinematography from Tami Reiker wasn’t necessarily bad, it just lacked creativity. It was mostly forgettable, and in such a vibrant setting, I thought they really could have used the location to their advantage. Give us some interesting camera angles, lively lighting…Anything to make the experience more memorable. Again, nothing about this film deserves legitimate hate, and I am still more than excited to see what King does next to improve on her still very promising start.
The final opinion is: A few aspects could use some attention, but One Night in Miami largely benefits from its important screenwriting and exceptional performances from its incredible cast…$PLURGE IT
Rating: R (for some language)
Genre: Drama
Runtime: 1 hour 50 minutes
Directed By: Regina King